Underwood is starring on the upcoming fourth season of The Traitors, which he says is "by far, one of the most exciting shows" he's ever been a part of. He stars alongside Ballas, Johnny Weir, Kristen Kish, Monét X Change, Caroline Stanbury, Donna Kelce, and Lisa Rinna, among others.

Leading up to his Traitors debut, Underwood returned to reality TV alongside Mirrorball Champion and fellow Bachelor Nation alum Kaitlyn Bristowe as cohosts for Hulu’s newest dating show, Are You My First? which follows 21 single virgins looking to find the one—or, the first one, at least.